A Discourse on American Style feat. Bruce Boyer

February 27th, 2015

Bruce Boyer has seen a lot of men’s fashion come and go. That’s why he sticks to his classic American “Ivy Style”.

With more than 40 years of experience as a men’s fashion editor, writer, and historian, you can bet he has a lot to say about the ever-popular #menswear industry. Bruce was the men’s fashion editor at Town & Country magazine for 15 years as well as a contributing writer to several major publications including Esquire, Harper’s Bazaare and the New York Times. He’s also one of the most prolific American authors on men’s style and fashion. He’s written several books on the history and direction of menswear, including Elegance: A Guide to Quality in Menswear,  Eminently SuitableRebel Style: Cinematic Heroes of the Fifties, and Gary Cooper: Enduring Style. He’s even a contributor to the Encyclopedia of Clothing and Fashion.

We met with Bruce a few weeks ago in freezing cold NYC to learn more about his journey in the business and, naturally, get some of his uncensored thoughts on the current state of men’s fashion and style in America.

mensstylebrucelen (21 of 44)

On Developing a Personal Style

“I think I developed an interest in clothing for two reasons. First I was slight as a child, a skinny little kid who had to find ways to protect himself in a tough neighborhood. So I hung around with the older guys, and quickly noticed their outward trappings: their clothes, their gestures and sense of humor, the way they walked, everything. The guys with the most style, the ones with an individual twist on things, got a lot of respect where I grew up.

Second, I was lucky to have had an incredibly tolerant mother, who allowed me to wear clothes of which she didn’t approve but tolerated. When I was a young man, a very young man (12 -16), I tried everything: zoot suits, rebel style , California casual, and everything else that was going on in the 50s. So I experimented a lot with “looks”. And that’s important: a young person should experiment, find out what works and what doesn’t. As you grow and discover who you are, you fine-tune your appearance to accommodate your personality and lifestyle.

As far as my outfit on this day, to my mind, it’s a country gentleman sort of look. Slightly rumpled, like me. The jacket is a 16-oz tan Scottish tweed with a faint blue overcheck. The trousers are a heavy, olive corduroy (flat front). The tie a green silk knit, horizontally self-striped from Italy. The sweater waistcoat is navy blue cashmere. The shoes are Scotch-grain derbies with rubber soles.”

mensstylebrucelen (19 of 44)

On Life in the Fast Lane

“I cut my teeth at Town & Country, as their first adjunct men’s fashion editor for 15 years. I couldn’t have had a better education because the 70s and 80s were a golden time. The legendary Frank Zachary was editor-in-chief (I wrote a tribute to him for the magazine last year on his 100th birthday). He was a great editor. He gave a young writer his head and let him follow his own style rather making him conform to anything.

It was the last age when magazines were stocked with eccentrics and money. The junkets were fabulous: I flew off to The Hebrides, South of France, Stockholm, wherever I found a story, really. We traveled to Milan and London regularly. You got to meet a lot of very interesting people, but I was always drawn to the clothing craftsmen, the real tailors and shirtmakers and bootmakers. They were more interesting than many of the designers.

With that said, I think the most elegant man I’ve ever known was Bill Blass. He wore the most beautiful clothes — he had tailors all over the world — had naturally perfect manners, a generous spirit, wonderful sense of humor, and spoke like a Cole Porter song. In many ways he was the epitome of true American style for me.”

On the Perils of Fashion Democracy

“Beginning after World War II, the way fashion works changed radically. From the historic initiation of fashion to almost mid-20th century, fashion started at the top of the social scale and worked its way down to the bottom. But starting in 1950 or so, fashion began to be determined from the bottom up. Designers, particularly from the late 60s on, began to look to the street for inspiration. The great American icons of fashion for men — jeans, T-shirts, “active” footwear, barn jackets, and the rest — all come from the street, the playing field, the war zone, and prole gear, rather than from the wealthy, the aristocratic and royal. It’s largely a democratic movement, with help from technology and a relatively stable economy. A hand-tailored wardrobe is today an infinitesimally small cut of the fashion pie. Tailored clothing generally has become a choice rather than a necessity for many businessmen. The whole historical movement in clothing, from the 20th century until today, has been towards casualness and comfort.

I tend to look at these things dispassionately because my taste is somewhat imprisoned by the years of my youth. I really haven’t had any “fashion phases” since I was 20 or so. I’ve concentrated more on finding purveyors who could give me what I wanted… I feel perfectly comfortable (in fact more comfortable) in a tweed sports jacket, dress shirt, tie, flannel trousers, and good leather shoes.

Interestingly, the insanity of the moment is guys who wear their tailored clothes much too tight. All those constricting little shiny suits that the Italian fashion herd has been pushing. Most of these guys look like they were poured into their clothes and forgot to say when. They look uncomfortable and make those of us who have to look at them uncomfortable. I think tailored clothes should have good shape, but by comfortable. I would never sacrifice comfort for fashion. But that’s what fashion is, isn’t it? Something so ridiculous, it’s got to be changed every season.”

mensstylebrucelen (18 of 44)

On Magazines and Bloggers

“Fashion is changing. I mean where it’s coming from is changing. Today the best men’s fashion magazines are the Japanese ones…The most interesting ideas are coming out of Hong Kong, Singapore, Tokyo. I think — and this is an attempt at a historical perspective — guys in that part of the world are taking ideas from the Americans, the Brits, the Italians , mixing it all up, and coming up with something unique…

I don’t really understand why we can’t produce a good men’s fashion magazine here in the USA, but at the moment we can’t… People used to get their fashion information and advice from magazines, but magazines have become lazy and safe and conservative. Editorial is too tied in with advertising – they’ve become too interested in promoting only the establishment money. Bloggers have gone around all that, they can promote what they want and do it faster. They give us all more choices, more perspective, more information. I think bloggers are responsible for men being more educated about their wardrobes today.

Of course there’s a lot of misinformation too, but there’s always been a lot of misinformation. An intelligent person will come to know which source to trust and which bloggers are just blowing smoke… I get most of my daily media information today from blog sites, rather than from magazines. There are at least a dozen site I visit religiously. I do think that anonymity isn’t helpful when it comes to people commenting on blog sites, though. There should be complete transparency and accountability in any sort of publishing.  That would help to get rid of much of the confusion.”

On Buying Quality & Having Faith

“My grandfather, an ordinary blue collar working man, had one good readymade suit and one sports jacket, one good pair of shoes, perhaps four or five dress shirts and as many ties. Today it seems that many have steaming piles of cheap clothing, but no good clothes. Even many luxury brands are no longer concerned with quality.

I think the reason is that, in today’s world, we’ve lost both the sense of occasion and a sense of quality. I do find this a bit frightening because I think it may mean we no longer think about the future. Those who are concerned for the ecology have been saying this for years now, and I’m worried that it may be true. We’re living too much for today, “getting and spending” as the poet William Wordsworth put it. And on an even deeper level, it means we may have no sense of faith in ourselves anymore.

It does seem to me that men used to dress in order to look better. I am optimistic that this idea will return, if for no other reason that we’re living in a global economy, competition is fierce, and the weapons of dress and grooming and manners will once again come into play.”

mensstylebrucelen (41 of 44)

Bruce with one of his favorite tailors, Len Logsdail (whom he helped get his start in America). 

Thanks, as always, for reading and special thanks to Bruce for participating! 

Yours in style,

Dan Trepanier

Shop Custom Menswear Made in America


Take me to the Shop

  • http://www.lucidlingo.com.au/ Gazman

    “Interestingly, the insanity of the moment is guys who wear their tailored clothes much too tight… Most of these guys look like they were
    poured into their clothes and forgot to say when. They look
    uncomfortable and make those of us who have to look at them

    Could not agree more! And good to see someone of note saying this.

  • ottovbvs

    100% agree with Bruce’s observations. I’m in a similar age group and went through the same learning curve. I joke that my clothes aren’t out of fashion because they were never in fashion. I will fess up to falling off the wagon a couple of times in the 70’s which in my lifetime was without question the nadir of popular men’s fashion although I suspect the flood pants and tight, short jackets probably aren’t going to look too good in photographs 30 years from now. Bruce puts his finger on it when he says men used to dress to look better. Not being Gary Cooper or Brad Pitt that’s exactly my goal but most men seem to have completely lost sight of this. Let’s join Bruce in hoping it returns, and soon.

  • Jaws

    Really great content all around. Thanks to Dan T. and team of Articles of Style for connecting with Boyer and Flusser for posts like this. This blog is really finding a good balance of delivering stuff for newcomers and posts which are of value to the history of mens clothes. An additional aspect of this site which could be interesting would be getting insight on brand/product from people involved with different companies in a more interview style format for some posts which could create more content to vary the posts from being outfit/photo centered.

  • http://ledebonnaire.tumblr.com/ Juan Zara

    “But that’s what fashion is, isn’t it? Something so ridiculous, it’s got to be changed every season”

    This pretty much sums up everything I believe in.

    Thank you Dan, AoS team, for yet another great article. Being (or at least trying to be) a Trad dresser myself, Bruce Boyer has always been a style icon of mine. I have admired him and his work since I read his contributions to the “Ivy Style” book that came out a few years ago, especially his description of the perfect wardrobe for college men in the 50s.

    I have since gotten his Gary Cooper book and loved every bit of it. And have been actively looking for his older books, which, sadly, are very hard to come by in Italy.

    On a more general note, I am truly glad to see Ivy style making a comeback, or at least getting more coverage. The Ivy League look is, to me, for its understated dressiness, the most versatile and best-looking look a man can put together. It treads the dressy/casual line Dan has been talking about better than any other “style” of male clothing, making it appropriate for basically any occasion.

    Some may disagree, some may say it’s not “authentic” or that it doesn’t represent their heritage/beliefs/whatever, but a man is always going to look better (proportionally speaking) wearing traditional Ivy gear rather than streetwear or “high-fashion” crap, simply because Ivy style is, as Mr. Boyer put it, about shape and comfort, while fashion and streetwear actually sacrifice shape and comfort for superficial (and, most of the time, tacky) embellishments and so-called “uniqueness”. Designers (and people in general) are so obsessed with coming up with something nobody else has done before that they forget dressing is about complementing one’s silhouette in order to look good.

    So long live 3-roll-2 jackets with 3″ lapels. Long live soft, natural, lightly padded shoulders. Long live four cuff buttons on suits and two cuff buttons on sportcoats, 11″ rises that make trousers sit at one’s actual waist, button down-collars with regimental striped ties (although Mr. Boyer’s wearing a very nice Viola Milano knitted tie here), ribbed wool socks in the winter and sockless penny loafers in the summer. Long live “cuff, no break”, and actually looking put together and proportionally harmonic, all the time.

  • Zane

    Great feature, as usual. I am just curious, when he says “most interesting ideas are coming out of Hong Kong, Singapore and Tokyo”, I assume he’s referring to fashion ideas. Did he say why and how these ideas are erecting from these countries? Because I am from Singapore, and the typical 30-35 degree weather makes it impossible for any gentleman to be concerned about what he’s going to wear today. Even with the extremely breathable linen, it is still a challenge…

    • http://ledebonnaire.tumblr.com/ Juan Zara

      I think it mainly has to do with the fact that the best menswear magazines today are published in those countries, namely “Lightning”, “Free and Easy” (Japan) and “The Rake” (Singapore.)

  • Stuart

    You’ve got to love the nod to Bill Blass. Respect.

  • Kyle Leon Norville

    Amazing feature. The comment about magazines is very valid. I have noticed a decline in actual content. To the point where I am no longer interested in the latest issue as much as I am when I look on blogs. Times are definitely changing.

  • TO

    One of the best reads I have had the pleasure of indulging in ever on this site. Mr. Boyer has some fantastic insights. I see myself returning to read this one time and time again.

  • Miguel

    Great article, very informative and some true in the magazines aspect, it’s more about the ads than the information.

  • Andrew

    Bruce Boyer is my style icon. I’m so glad to see you feature him.

  • JoeFromTexas

    “There are at least a dozen site I visit religiously.” – I would love to see that list!

    • James Wong

      I second this please!

  • JoeFromTexas

    “my taste is somewhat imprisoned by the years of my youth” – what a beautiful way to put an almost universal affliction.

    • TO

      Loved that quote as well